There’s a leadership communication crisis hiding in plain sight right now. And it’s not what most people think.
It’s not that leaders aren’t saying enough. If anything, they’re saying more than ever. Town halls, all-staff emails, leadership podcasts, video updates, cascaded messaging, intranet posts. The volume has never been higher. But trust in leadership? Never lower. Gallup found only 23% of US employees strongly agree they trust their organisation’s leadership. A DDI survey of 11,000 leaders found trust in immediate managers collapsed from 46% in 2022 to just 29% in 2024.
And PwC’s Global Workforce Hopes and Fears Survey found barely half of workers trust top management at all.
More communication. Less trust. How does that happen? Here’s what I reckon is going on.
The problem isn’t the message. It’s the voice delivering it.
We’re living through a moment where AI can produce polished, well-structured, gramatically spotless internal communication faster than any human comms team. So organisations are drowning in content. Project updates, leadership announcements, strategic priorities, change initiatives – all landing in inboxes and on intranets and in Slack channels, all signalling urgency, all scrapping for the same exhausted emplyee attention. And employees have clocked it. They can feel the difference between a message that’s been crafted to sound human and one that actually is. When everything reads the same; same beats, same format, same carefully managed tone – people stop taking it in. It’s not that they’re disengaged. It’s just nothing’s giving them a reason to lean in.
Content isn’t the thing that cuts through. A voice people actually trust cuts through. Which is, handily, a very learnable thing. When I work with senior leaders and spokespeople on their leadership communication skills, we’re often not touching what they say. That’s gone through more hands than a relay baton (comms, PR, legal, senior leadership, and probably someone’s golf buddy who “had a few thoughts.”) I can sometimes reshape the flow, like move a phrase, break a sentence differently so it sits more naturally in someone’s mouth. But the message itself is often, frustratingly, sacred! What we’re doing is making sure a real human being can actually deliver it like they mean it.
Because here’s what happens when they can’t. A leader who rushes the difficult bit of a town hall sounds like they can’t wait to get it over with. A spokesperson who flattens their tone when nerves kick in sounds like they’re reading a press release someone else wrote. A podcast host who disconnects from the script the moment the mic goes live sounds, at best, wooden and at worst, like someone you wouldn’t trust with the tea round.
None of these people are lying or bad at their jobs. Their voice is just working against them at the exact moment it matters most.
Voice coaching for leaders fixes this. Not by making people sound posh or over-produced or like a different version of themselves. By helping them sound like a more grounded, present, connected version of who they already are. Pace that gives the message room to land. Tone that shifts with the meaning behind the words. Presence that tells a room, the listener, that this person actually means what they’re saying.
That’s what builds trust. It’s not about volume of communication, production quality or slide deck… The leaders cutting through right now are the ones who sound real. Who can sit in front of a camera or stand at a lectern during genuine uncertainty and come across as human. If your people already know what to say (and I bet most of them do!) the question worth asking is whether the voice delivering it is earning trust or quietly eroding it. That’s the gap I work in. And right now, it might be the most important gap there is.
Have a nosey at my listing in the Expert Directory and let’s have a proper chat about where voice work could make the biggest difference for your leaders.