By Debbie Bailey
If you gave someone in your organisation a pay rise in April and they are still distracted, still looking tired and still don’t seem completely happy, the reason usually sits in the habits and beliefs they have around money, and a pay rise alone can’t change those.
I knew an accountant who had no real idea what was leaving his bank account each month. He had moved house and was still paying the energy bills on the old one, and it was months before he noticed the double direct debits. Even though he was earning well, he wasn’t looking at his finances, and that left him missing important things.
When he got a pay rise, his spending expanded to eat it up. He wasn’t reckless with it, he spent a bit more on meals out, had an extra night away, picked up an extra coffee and paid for his mates more often. The extra money disappeared because he carried on with the same habits, spending a bit more here and there.
The same thing happens inside organisations. The employee who got the pay rise hasn’t touched the pension or the benefits you are paying for either, which means your organisation is paying more in salary and benefits and getting the same level of focus back. Another pay rise on its own won’t change that.
Why a pay rise only goes so far
What happened to that accountant has a name, lifestyle creep. It’s when spending gradually rises to match whatever someone earns, so a pay rise never really feels like extra money. It builds up through lots of small things that slowly become normal, like the takeaway that used to be a treat becoming a weekly habit, or the cheaper supermarket being swapped for the nicer one without really thinking about it. I see it with people at every level of an organisation, because nobody has ever sat down with them and helped them decide what they want the extra money to do for them. So the person who was struggling on £2,000 a month finds they are still struggling on £3,000, and it feels just as tight as it did before.
For your organisation, that means you are paying a higher salary and still have someone whose mind is on their bank balance and home worries instead of being fully focused on their work.
Why financial stress is rising this winter
On top of that, this winter is putting even more pressure on people. The Budget gave around 20 million households in council tax bands A to D a £100 payment towards their energy bills, which will start arriving in January. That will help, but it won’t go far when energy prices are forecast to rise sharply again in the new year. The Bank of England is also expected to put interest rates up this week for the first time since 2023, and with more than two million fixed-rate mortgages due to end next year, a lot of people are about to see their monthly payments jump.
That pressure will impact people in your teams at every pay grade, including the ones who have just had a pay rise. When someone is worried about money, they bring that worry to work with them. They are more tired than usual, take longer over decisions and make small mistakes they wouldn’t normally make, and some are scrolling mortgage deals or job adverts on their lunch break. Others start side hustles to bring in extra money, which eats into the time and energy they have for the role you are paying them to do.
If you’re seeing this in your organisation, you can find out more about how I support businesses with employee financial wellbeing here: https://expertservicesdirectory.com/directory/debbie-bailey/
What financial stress is costing your organisation
From the outside, it can look like nothing much has changed, which is why it’s so easy to miss. What I see instead is the same pay conversation coming round every six months, employee benefits that you are funding but hardly anyone is using, and managers spending more and more of their time supporting people who used to be some of their most reliable.
Eventually, a good employee leaves for a slightly bigger salary somewhere else, hoping that will finally make the difference. That leaves you paying to recruit and train their replacement, while all the investment the organisation committed in that person and everything they knew about the role walks out of the door with them.
The gap salary can’t close
Most financial stress comes down to behaviour, the habits, beliefs and emotional reactions to money that people picked up long before they joined your organisation. For some people money always felt scarce growing up, for others it was never talked about at all, and a lot of people carry around a belief that they are not good with money. When a pay rise is given, those old patterns carry on just as they were.
That’s why pay works so much better when it sits alongside structured financial wellbeing support. The support reaches the part salary can’t, which is the confidence, the behaviour and the stories people tell themselves about what’s possible for them financially.
Talk Money Week is a good moment to ask
Talk Money Week is this week, with lots of encouragement to talk more openly about money, but once it’s over things usually go back to how they were. It’s a good moment to ask a more practical question in your own organisation: are we giving people the income to cope, without giving them the tools to feel in control of it?
When those tools are missing, people don’t engage with their pension even though you are contributing to it, they don’t use the benefits you have invested in, and they put off financial decisions until they become urgent. Most of them won’t ask for help either, because admitting they don’t understand something feels embarrassing. So the only conversation you end up having with them about money is the one about their salary, because for most people that is the obvious thing to focus on. The assumption is that a pay rise means more cash in the bank and therefore fewer worries.
If you’re thinking about how this is showing up across your teams, you can explore what financial wellbeing support could look like for you here: https://expertservicesdirectory.com/directory/debbie-bailey/
What’s behind the pay rise request
When someone asks for a pay rise, it’s always worth thinking about what they’re really asking for. A lot of the time it’s about being paid the market rate or feeling recognised for what they do, and that matters. Sometimes, though, underneath it there’s a feeling of being out of control, of never quite having enough no matter what they earn, and of not knowing what else they could ask for.
What financial wellbeing support looks like in practice
Financial wellbeing support gives employees something to go alongside their pay. In practice, that includes:
- Workshops that explore the money habits and beliefs people have carried since childhood, so that employees stop repeating the same patterns every time their income goes up.
- Practical sessions on budgeting, bills and subscriptions, so that people know where their money goes each month and can plan for rising energy and mortgage costs instead of being caught out by them.
- Pension and benefits sessions, so that employees understand and use what you are already paying for and you get a better return on that spend.
- Group coaching over several weeks, so that new habits stick long after the first session and the change shows up in focus and performance at work.
- Sessions for line managers, so that they spot the early signs of financial stress and know where to point people, instead of absorbing it themselves.
What changes when you get this right
The change doesn’t happen overnight, but you do notice it. People finally open their pension statement and start asking questions about it. They begin using the benefits that were there all along, and they deal with things earlier instead of waiting until something forces their hand. Over time, the pay conversation that used to come round every six months comes round a lot less often.
I have seen it first hand. People become confident enough to negotiate their monthly bills with suppliers, they realise how much they have been spending on subscriptions they don’t use, and they have the conversation with their mortgage broker six months before the deal is due to end. Bit by bit, they feel more in control of their money and a lot less stressed about it.
For your organisation, that means people with more headspace to focus on their work, fewer reactive pay requests, and a much better return on the benefits you are already paying for.
Why I do this work (and how it impacts organisations positively)
I spent years in FTSE 100 finance teams, where performance was measured closely and hidden costs were picked up quickly, which means I look at financial wellbeing the way a finance team looks at any other cost to the business.
I also grew up in a household where money was scarce and stressful, and where it felt like we could never have more, which means I understand why people avoid looking at their finances and why more information on its own rarely changes that. Putting the two together, I design programmes that speak to the numbers your leadership team cares about and to the behaviour your employees need to change.
You can keep increasing salaries and hope something changes underneath, or you can start looking at the part of the equation that a pay rise was never going to fix.
If you’d like to understand what practical, behaviour-led financial wellbeing support could look like in your organisation, you can find more about my work and get in touch here: https://expertservicesdirectory.com/directory/debbie-bailey/